Matthew Colantonio

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Matthew Colantonio
Lic. Associate Real Estate Broker
matt@schuckmanrealty.com

Matt Colantonio graduated from Brown University in 2011 with bachelor’s degrees in Economics and History. After Brown, Matt went on to play four years of professional baseball in the San Diego Padres and Cleveland Indians organizations. In the later years of his baseball career, he began working at NYC middle-markets powerhouse Massey Knakal in the offseason, and later joined full-time as an Investment Sales Associate specializing in the Downtown Manhattan markets. After 4 years with Massey Knakal and 6 months at Cushman & Wakefield, who acquired Massey Knakal in 2014, Matt joined Schuckman Realty Inc. and has worked primarily Investment Sales throughout all NY Metro markets and asset classes and has recently expanded into the national single-tenant net lease investment sales market.

Some of his more prominent transactions include the $17.5M sale of 92 Main Street in Yonkers, the $16M sale of 998 Franklin Ave in Garden City, the $6.6M sale of the Maggiano’s at the Roosevelt Field Mall, the $5.3M sale of 2 Lincoln Ave in Rockville Centre, and the retail leasing of 150 E 42nd Street in Manhattan. Matt recently opened Schuckman’s West Coast Office in Orange County, CA, is a member of ICSC, was recognized in 2017 as one of Commercial Observer’s 30 Under 30, and is an avid golfer.

Notable Transactions:
998 Franklin Ave, Garden City – SOLD: $16,000,000
600 Garden City Plaza, Garden City – SOLD: $6,600,000
92 Main St, Yonkers – SOLD: $17,500,000
86 Main St, Yonkers – SOLD: $9,500,000
2 Lincoln Ave, Rockville Centre – SOLD: $5,260,000
3274 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside – SOLD: $2,598,343
565 Westfield Ave W, Roselle Park, NJ – SOLD: $2,721,000
710 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood – SOLD: $2,500,000
220 Jericho Tpke, Syosset -SOLD: $2,500,000
199 E Jericho Tpke, Mineola – SOLD: $6,200,000
1968 Jerome Ave, Bronx -SOLD: $3,350,000
1732 Webster Ave, Bronx, -SOLD: $2,878,500

Schuckman Realty Announces $14.7M Sale of 137-20 Cross Bay Boulevard in Ozone Park

By Baruch Edelkopf Matthew Colantonio Steven Hakakian

Ozone Park, NY – February 26, 2025 – Schuckman Realty Inc. is pleased to announce the successful sale of 137-20 Cross Bay Boulevard, a 32,000-square-foot retail center, for $14.7 million. The transaction closed…

Read More

Schuckman Realty Seeking Investment Sales Associates

By Matthew Colantonio

This is a full-time mostly on-site role for an Investment Sales Associate within the experienced and growing Investment Sales Team at Schuckman Realty Inc. The Investment Sales Associate will be responsible for research,…

Read More

Colantonio of Schuckman Realty Sells Long Island CVS Property for $4.05 Million

By Matthew Colantonio

A retail property in Huntington Station has sold for $4.05 million. 111 Depot Realty LLC, an affiliate of a Long Island-based commercial real estate investor, purchased the 11,865-square-foot building on 1.24 acres at…

Read More

ICSC New York – December 11 & 12, 2024 – Schuckman Realty

By Ari Malul Baruch Edelkopf Carter Clark Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS ... Jack Pierce Jessica Vilmenay John Roos ... Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Sam Schertz Ryan Adhami Stanley Schuckman Steven Hakakian

Schuckman Realty attended the ICSC New York Convention on December 11-12, 2024, held at the Javits Convention Center on Manhattan’s West Side. The team at Schuckman Realty were located at booth 925 and…

Read More

Prime Corner Retail Space Available for Lease in TriBeCa

By Ari Malul Matthew Colantonio Kenneth Schuckman

261 Broadway, New York, NY | New York, NY 10007 5,500 SF Corner with Wrap-Around Frontage Retail Space Available.Property also includes a 3,000 SF Basement.High Foot Traffic & Exceptional Visibility.Directly across from City…

Read More

Schuckman Realty, will be at ICSC New York, December 11-12, 2024 at the Javits Convention Center

By Baruch Edelkopf Brian Boker Carter Clark Eugene McLaughlin Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS ... Jack Pierce Jessica Vilmenay John Roos ... ... Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Ryan Adhami Sam Schertz Stanley Schuckman Steven Hakakian

Schuckman Realty, will attend the ICSC New York Convention, December 11-12, 2024 at the Javits Convention Center on Manhattan’s West Side. The team at Schuckman Realty can be found at booth 925 by…

Read More

Just Listed. Automotive Repair Building & Property For Sale.72 Terry St. Patchogue, NY 11772

By Eugene McLaughlin Matthew Colantonio

Just Listed. Automotive Repair Building & Property For Sale.72 Terry St. Patchogue, NY 11772. Featuring a 3,400 SF Automotive Building on .26 Acres with 70’  of frontage on Terry Street and high visibility….

Read More

Schuckman Realty Investment Sales Team Welcomes New Team Members Jordan Cardenas and Carter Clark

By Carter Clark ... Matthew Colantonio Baruch Edelkopf

Rockville Centre, NY., Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the addition of Jordan Cardenas and Carter Clark to its investment sales team Jordan Cardenas, a licensed real estate salesperson will focus on retail,…

Read More

Schuckman Realty Investment Sales Team Leader, Matthew Colantonio named by NYREJ as a “Ones to Watch, Industry Leader”

By Matthew Colantonio

May 28, 2024 – New York Real Estate Journal: New York, NY: Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce that Matthew Colantonio has been named an NYREJ Ones to Watch Industry Leader for 2024….

Read More

The Four “D’s” of Real Estate Investment Sales

By John Roos Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Sam Schertz Steven Hakakian Baruch Edelkopf Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS

In the complex and ever-evolving world of real estate investment, several critical factors can prompt the sale of a property. Among these, the “Four D’s”—Death, Divorce, Debt, and Divestment due to Dispute or…

Read More

Schuckman Realty Inc. to Showcase at ICSC Las Vegas 2024 with X Team Retail Advisors

By Ari Malul Baruch Edelkopf Brian Boker Jessica Vilmenay John Roos ... Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Ryan Adhami Stanley Schuckman Steven Hakakian

Rockville Centre, NY – Schuckman Realty Inc., a leading real estate firm known for its innovative approach in the retail property market, is excited to announce its participation at ICSC Las Vegas, Nevada….

Read More

Schuckman Realty will be at ICSC NY, Dec 6-7, 2023 – Javits Center, Manhattan

By Ari Malul Baruch Edelkopf Brian Boker Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS Jack Pierce Jessica Vilmenay John Roos ... Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Ryan Adhami Sam Schertz Stanley Schuckman Steven Hakakian

Schuckman Realty, which is celebrating 45 years in business in 2023 will be at the ICSC New York Convention, December 6-7, 2023 at the Javits Convention Center on Manhattan’s West Side. The team…

Read More

Colantonio of Schuckman Realty Facilitates Sale of Single-Tenant Leased Property in Oceanside

By Matthew Colantonio

Oceanside, NY; Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the sale of a single-tenant leased property at 3200 Long Beach Road, Oceanside, NY 11572. The property features an 11,500 square foot building on a…

Read More

Schuckman Realty & Kenneth Schuckman named among Top Leasing Firms and Top Leasing Broker by CoStar

By Ari Malul Baruch Edelkopf Brian Boker Denise Norcia John Roos ... Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Ryan Adhami Sam Schertz Stanley Schuckman Steven Hakakian

We are pleased to announce that Schuckman Realty has again been named a CoStar Top Leasing Firm for the Long Island Market for 2022. In addition, Schuckman Realty’s president and CEO, Kenneth Schuckman…

Read More

Schuckman Realty, Building on Decades of Experience, Hits 45 Year Milestone.

By Ari Malul Jessica Vilmenay Kenneth Schuckman Stanley Schuckman Baruch Edelkopf Brian Boker Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS ... John Roos ... Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Ryan Adhami Sam Schertz

Rockville Centre, NY Schuckman Realty Inc., a full service commercial real estate services firm serving Metropolitan New York and the surrounding tri-state area is celebrating 45 years of serving the business community. The…

Read More

Schuckman Realty Investment Sales 2022 Highlights

By Baruch Edelkopf Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS Kenneth Schuckman ... Matthew Colantonio Mendy Wiesner Sam Schertz Steven Hakakian

Schuckman Realty’s Investment Sales team offers expertise along all asset classes within the NYC-Metro, Long Island, and surrounding markets in determining a property’s best use in terms of value to our clients, owners,…

Read More

Colantonio and Gottlieb of Schuckman Realty Facilitate Sale of Single-Tenant Net Leased Citibank Building in Richmond Hill

By Matthew Colantonio Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS

Queens, NY; Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the sale of a single-tenant net leased Citibank located at 121-11 Liberty Avenue, South Richmond Hill, Queens, NY 11419. The building which is located on…

Read More

Colantonio and Hakakian of Schuckman Realty Facilitate Sale of Orange County, NY Shopping Center

By Matthew Colantonio Steven Hakakian

New Windsor, NY; Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the sale of a 52,000 square foot, grocery anchored shopping center at 436 Blooming Grove Turnpike New Windsor, NY 12553. The 100% leased, Blooming…

Read More

Colantonio and Adhami of Schuckman Realty Facilitate Sale of Long Island STNL Bank Building

By Matthew Colantonio Ryan Adhami

Colantonio and Adhami of Schuckman Realty Facilitate Sale of Long Island STNL Bank Building Brentwood, NY; The Schuckman Realty Investment Sales team is proud to announce that team members Matthew Colantonio and Ryan…

Read More

Colantonio and Malul of Schuckman Realty Fill and Sell Trophy Multi-Tenant Retail Property in Garden City

By Ari Malul Matthew Colantonio

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Colantonio and Malul of Schuckman Realty Fill and Sell Trophy Multi-Tenant Retail Property in Garden City Garden City, NY; Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the sale of a seven-tenant,…

Read More

Schuckman Realty Investment Sales Team Tabbed for over $45,500,000 worth of Retail with Parking Exclusives in Q3.

By Baruch Edelkopf Steven Hakakian Mendy Wiesner Stanley Schuckman Kenneth Schuckman Matthew Colantonio

Rockville Centre & NYC Bryant Park, NY: Schuckman Realty has been exclusively retained to sell five separate retail properties, all with parking, during Q3 2021. Accentuated by the Covid-19 Pandemic, customers, tenants, and…

Read More

Colantonio and Gottlieb of Schuckman Realty Sell Single-Tenant 7-Eleven in Oceanside

By Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS Matthew Colantonio

Oceanside, NY; Schuckman Realty is pleased to announce the sale of a single tenant 7-Eleven asset at 65 Atlantic Avenue, located in Oceanside, NY. 7-Eleven has been operating at this location since 2006….

Read More

Downtown Yonkers – Full Building For Lease or Sale, 4,500 SF – 5 Woodworth Avenue, Yonkers, NY

By Matthew Colantonio

Full Building For Lease or Sale, 4,500 SF 5 Woodworth Avenue, Yonkers, NY Steps to Yonkers MTA Station Drive – In Bays First Floor 1,500 SF Retail Space Residential/Work Space on 2nd &…

Read More

Colantonio and Gottlieb of Schuckman Realty Represent Buyer and Seller in $6.6M Restaurant Property Sale. Garden City, NY

By Edward Gottlieb, CRX, CLS Matthew Colantonio

Garden City retail property sells for $6.6M Matt Colantonio and Edward Gottlieb of Schuckman Realty represented the buyer and the seller, in sale of Restaurant property adjacent to Roosevelt Field Mall. The 8,893-square-foot…

Read More